I have to keep this quick, but I'm responding now because there will be a narrow window during which you can register and get the membership for $14.95 instead of $19.95. If you do the 'sit back and wait' routine, that specific opportunity will go away. Once the first 100 ppl register, starting Saturday morning, that program will close.
CAP is on my list of organizations to work with, but I don't know what the final package will look like. It's too early to say. A few ppl from CAP have contacted me in the past, but haven't followed up.
if I have to put out money to fly why not do it rw and log it rather than play a game
Simple, this will save you time and money on your instrument ticket, and allow you to reach a level of comfort and proficiency during your training that would not be financially realistic to undertake in an airplane.
How many approach clearances, route clearances and hours of logged time is your $15 going to get you in a real airplane?
The frequent flier program is primarily aimed at sim enthusiasts who are not currently paying ANYTHING for r/w flying and are looking for an alternative to having to pay for this. A real world pilot is in a position to SAVE money on their flight training.
$15-20/mth is considered a bargain by those who use this for training and proficiency. I noticed you used the word 'game'. When you connect the sim to an environment like this, it ceases to be one and really can be a productive training tool.